Skip to:

  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to accessibility
City, University of London
  • Student Hub
  • Staff Hub
Search
Menu
Home
  • Prospective students
    • Courses
      • Undergraduate degrees
      • Apprenticeships
      • Foundation courses
      • Postgraduate taught degrees
      • Postgraduate research degrees
      • Short courses
      • Professional development courses
        • My Home Life England Bitesize Programme (Online)
      • City Health courses
    • Apply
      • Entry requirements
      • How to apply
        • Undergraduate
        • Apprenticeship
        • Information for teachers
        • Postgraduate taught
        • Postgraduate research
          • Preparing your application
            • Preparing your research proposal
          • All PhD research projects
        • Booking Short Courses
          • Business and Management Short Courses
          • Computing Short Courses
          • Creative Industry Short Courses
          • Creative Writing Short Courses
            • The Novel Studio published alumni
          • Law Short Courses
          • Languages Courses Online | Languages Courses in London
      • Prospectus
        • Undergraduate
        • Postgraduate
      • Visas
        • Student visas
          • Applying from outside the UK
          • Applying from within the UK
          • Applying for a dependant visa
          • Preparing your application
          • Working in the UK
        • Standard Visitor visas
          • How to apply for a Standard Visitor Visa
          • Non-visa nationals
        • ATAS certificates
        • Brexit and European nationals
      • Study abroad programmes
        • Study abroad programme
        • Partnership programme
      • Clearing
        • Applying through Clearing
      • Alternative entry routes
        • Foundation programmes
        • Second-year students
        • Work experience
      • Contact Admissions
    • Finance
      • Funding options
      • Earn while you learn
      • How to pay
        • Payment methods
        • Fee schedules
        • Deposit refunds
      • Additional expenses
    • Accommodation and housing
      • Compare residential halls
      • Applying for halls
        • Undergraduate
        • Postgraduate
        • Clearing
      • Paying for halls
      • Private accommodation
        • Finding a place to live
        • Accommodation for families
      • Short-term accommodation
    • Open events and fairs
      • Campus tours
      • Online chats
        • Undergraduate online events
        • Postgraduate online events
        • Ask a student
      • University fairs
    • Student life
      • London experience
      • Local area
      • Sports
        • Sport clubs
        • Non-competitive sport
        • Competitive sport
      • Social activities and groups
      • Religion
      • Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer plus
      • Volunteering
      • Student wellbeing
        • Your health and wellbeing
        • Learning support
        • Young, estranged students
        • Care leavers
        • Young adult carers
        • Personal tutoring programme
      • Learn another language
    • Career development
      • Placements, internships and employment opportunities
        • Micro-placements
      • Career pathways
      • Job prospects and graduate destinations
      • Careers team
    • Subjects
  • Research
    • Research centres and groups
    • Research impact
      • Research Excellence Framework
      • Research case studies
    • Research strategy
    • Research support
      • Grants and funding
      • Integrity and ethics
        • Research ethics
          • Principles
          • Approval process
          • Approval outcomes and appeals
          • External ethics approvals
        • Ethics guidance and resources
          • Participant information and consent
          • Recruiting participants from City
          • Records management
          • Research conducted abroad
          • FAQ
        • Research integrity
          • Framework for good practice in research
          • Research misconduct
      • Research data
        • Managing active research data
        • Digital research data and Figshare
      • Researcher development
    • City Doctoral College
      • Prospective Doctoral Researchers
      • Current Doctoral Researchers
      • Doctoral Training Resources
        • Doctoral Researcher Development Programme (DRDP)
      • Scholarships and Funding
      • For Research Supervisors
      • Meet the Team
  • For businesses
    • Start your business
      • Develop your startup idea
        • One-to-one startup advice
        • The Good Entrepreneur Festival
        • Startup Camp
        • Startup Seminars
        • Side Hustle
        • CitySpark Workshops
      • Launch your startup
        • Start-up visa
        • Launch Lab
    • Grow your business
      • Fund your business
        • Knowledge Transfer Partnerships
      • Hire an academic consultant
      • Purchase our intellectual property
      • Companies formed
    • Develop your people
      • Bespoke training
      • My Home Life England
      • Degree apprenticeships for business
        • What is the apprenticeship levy?
    • Business impact case studies
    • Access our student talent
      • Recruit with us
      • Meet and support our students
        • Become a mentor
        • Employer engagement events
        • Micro-Placements
        • Industry Led Projects
      • Information for placement partners
        • Speech and Language Therapy training
  • Alumni and supporters
    • Alumni benefits
    • Alumni Events
    • Global alumni network
      • Networks and Groups
        • City Alumni LinkedIn groups
        • MENA Alumni Board
        • US Alumni Board
      • Alumni Ambassadors
      • Special Interest Groups
      • Alumni News and stories
    • Contact us
    • Support City
      • Donate to City
      • Volunteering
      • Your impact
  • News and events
    • News
    • Events
    • Social media directory
      • City social accounts
        • WeChat social accounts
      • School and Departmental accounts
  • About us
    • Schools and Departments
      • School of Policy & Global Affairs
        • About the School
          • Athena Swan
        • Department of Economics
        • Department of International Politics
        • Department of Sociology and Criminology
          • Postgraduate Sociology at City
      • School of Communication & Creativity
        • About the School
          • Athena Swan
          • Creatives in Residence
        • Department of Journalism
          • James Cameron Memorial Lecture
            • Lectures
            • Special awards
            • Winners
        • Department of Media, Culture and Creative Industries
          • English, Publishing and Creative Writing
          • Culture and the Creative Industries
          • Library and Information Science
          • Media and Communications
        • Department of Performing Arts
        • The Centre for Language Studies
      • Bayes Business School
      • School of Health & Psychological Sciences
        • About the School
          • Athena SWAN
          • Selection Process
          • Occupational Health Checks
          • Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) enhanced check (formerly CRB)
          • MSc Nursing - RPL
          • Reference request
        • Department of Health Services Research and Management
          • Health Services Management at City
        • Department of Language and Communication Science
        • Department of Midwifery and Radiography
          • Radiography undergraduate learning contract
          • Postgraduate Midwifery at City
          • Radiography at City
        • Department of Nursing
        • Department of Optometry and Visual Sciences
        • Department of Psychology
      • School of Science & Technology
        • About the School
          • Athena Swan
          • Placements and internships
            • Placement and internship schemes
        • Department of Computer Science
        • Department of Mathematics
          • Potential PhD projects
        • Department of Engineering
      • The City Law School
        • Academic programmes
          • Undergraduate degree LLB
          • Graduate Entry Law GE LLB
          • Graduate Diploma in Law GDL
          • Master of Laws (LLM)
        • Professional programmes
        • Research and Scholarship
        • Athena Swan in The City Law School
        • Equality, Diversity and Inclusion at The City Law School
        • Barrister training
          • Bar Training
          • Pupillage Advisory Service
        • Solicitor training
          • Future Solicitor Advisory Service (FSAS)
          • The Solicitors' Qualifying Exam (SQE)
        • Law in real life (Law IRL)
          • Legal work placements
          • Court visits
          • Mock Trials
        • About The School
          • Prizes from The City Law School
          • Global Engagement
      • Dubai Centre
    • History
    • People
      • Academics
      • Research students
      • Students
      • Honorary graduates
      • Past students
      • Professional Services staff
      • International agents and representatives
      • Senior people
      • Extraordinary women
    • Facilities
      • Campuses
      • Libraries
      • Gym
      • University of London facilities
      • Specialist facilities
    • Work for us
      • Apply
      • Benefits
      • Career development
    • Vision and Strategy
      • Academic excellence
        • Rankings
        • Education
          • Flexible learning spaces
          • Active and collaborative learning
          • Term dates
        • Student statistics
      • Equality, diversity and inclusion
        • Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Strategy
        • Data and objectives
        • Staff networks
        • Digital Accessibility
      • Sustainable development
        • Get involved
        • Environmental Impact and Performance
      • Civic engagement
      • Social responsibility
        • Social responsibility in our outreach
        • Social responsibility in action
    • Governance and legal
      • Charter and Statutes
      • Rector
      • Council
        • Audit and Risk Committee
        • Corporate Governance and Nominations Committee
        • Remuneration Committee
        • Strategy and Finance Committee
        • Development Committee
      • Senate
        • Board of Studies
        • Collaborative Provision Committee
        • Educational Quality Committee
        • Research and Enterprise Committee
        • Senate Research Ethics Committee
      • Executive leadership
      • Financial statements
        • Financial Summary
      • Legal documents and policies
      • Committees
    • Global City
    • Contact us and find us
      • Find us
      • Contact us
      • Staff directory
  • Student Hub
  • Staff Hub
  • Prospective students
    Prospective students
    • Courses
      • Undergraduate degrees
      • Apprenticeships
      • Foundation courses
      • Postgraduate taught degrees
      • Postgraduate research degrees
      • Short courses
      • Professional development courses
      • City Health courses
    • Apply
      • Entry requirements
      • How to apply
      • Prospectus
      • Visas
      • Study abroad programmes
      • Clearing
      • Alternative entry routes
      • Contact Admissions
    • Finance
      • Funding options
      • Earn while you learn
      • How to pay
      • Additional expenses
    • Accommodation and housing
      • Compare residential halls
      • Applying for halls
      • Paying for halls
      • Private accommodation
      • Short-term accommodation
    • Open events and fairs
      • Campus tours
      • Online chats
      • University fairs
    • Student life
      • London experience
      • Local area
      • Sports
      • Social activities and groups
      • Religion
      • Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer plus
      • Volunteering
      • Student wellbeing
      • Learn another language
    • Career development
      • Placements, internships and employment opportunities
      • Career pathways
      • Job prospects and graduate destinations
      • Careers team
    • Subjects
  • Research
    Research
    • Research centres and groups
    • Research impact
      • Research Excellence Framework
      • Research case studies
    • Research strategy
    • Research support
      • Grants and funding
      • Integrity and ethics
      • Research data
      • Researcher development
    • City Doctoral College
      • Prospective Doctoral Researchers
      • Current Doctoral Researchers
      • Doctoral Training Resources
      • Scholarships and Funding
      • For Research Supervisors
      • Meet the Team
  • For businesses
    For businesses
    • Start your business
      • Develop your startup idea
      • Launch your startup
    • Grow your business
      • Fund your business
      • Hire an academic consultant
      • Purchase our intellectual property
      • Companies formed
    • Develop your people
      • Bespoke training
      • My Home Life England
      • Degree apprenticeships for business
    • Business impact case studies
    • Access our student talent
      • Recruit with us
      • Meet and support our students
      • Information for placement partners
  • Alumni and supporters
    Alumni and supporters
    • Alumni benefits
    • Alumni Events
    • Global alumni network
      • Networks and Groups
      • Alumni Ambassadors
      • Special Interest Groups
      • Alumni News and stories
    • Contact us
    • Support City
      • Donate to City
      • Volunteering
      • Your impact
  • News and events
    News and events
    • News
    • Events
    • Social media directory
      • City social accounts
      • School and Departmental accounts
  • About us
    About us
    • Schools and Departments
      • School of Policy & Global Affairs
      • School of Communication & Creativity
      • Bayes Business School
      • School of Health & Psychological Sciences
      • School of Science & Technology
      • The City Law School
      • Dubai Centre
    • History
    • People
      • Academics
      • Research students
      • Students
      • Honorary graduates
      • Past students
      • Professional Services staff
      • International agents and representatives
      • Senior people
      • Extraordinary women
    • Facilities
      • Campuses
      • Libraries
      • Gym
      • University of London facilities
      • Specialist facilities
    • Work for us
      • Apply
      • Benefits
      • Career development
    • Vision and Strategy
      • Academic excellence
      • Equality, diversity and inclusion
      • Sustainable development
      • Civic engagement
      • Social responsibility
    • Governance and legal
      • Charter and Statutes
      • Rector
      • Council
      • Senate
      • Executive leadership
      • Financial statements
      • Legal documents and policies
      • Committees
    • Global City
    • Contact us and find us
      • Find us
      • Contact us
      • Staff directory
  1. Home
  2. …
  3. Research impact
  4. Research case studies
  5. Evidence-based birthplace choices for women and birthing people
Research impact
  • Research Excellence Framework
  • Research case studies
Female student in nurse's uniform looking at a female patient in hospital
Research case study

Evidence-based birthplace choices for women and birthing people

Understanding the benefits of midwifery units and how we can encourage greater provision and quality

The researchers:

  • Dr Lucia Rocca-Ihenacho (Principal Investigator)
  • Professor Christine McCourt (Principal Investigator)
  • Dr Cassandra Yuill (Co-Investigator)
  • Dr Marina Daniele (Co-Investigator)
  • Dr Nathalie Leister (Co-Investigator)
  • Dr Susan Bradley (Co-Investigator)
  • Professor Alison Macfarlane (Co-Investigator)

Research status:Ongoing

This is impact: Is a hospital the best place to give birth? 2 minutes

In summary

Since the 1970s, researchers at City, University of London have worked to improve the quality and safety of childbirth.

There is a long-standing assumption about the superiority of hospital births but through a series of studies looking at midwifery units (also called birth centres) and home births, our academics have shown that’s simply not true for straightforward pregnancies.

Now the Centre for Maternal and Child Health Research is focusing on next steps: How can the healthcare system change its mindset and culture? How can the country scale up the number of midwifery units? What’s the best way to make sure these beneficial services get used?

What did we explore and how?

It’s easy for professionals to recommend a hospital birth – that way of thinking is embedded across healthcare services but it’s not based on evidence. In fact, the evidence can point to the opposite: For healthy women with straightforward pregnancies, midwifery units are associated with better outcomes and experiences and are also more cost-effective.

Improving awareness and acceptance of different birth settings among professionals is a major challenge but it will affect pregnant women everywhere. Benefits in these settings include reduced risk of maternal health complications which require admission to higher level of care, blood transfusion and longer postnatal hospital admission.  Service users and staff also have more positive experiences.

City has decades of research to draw on. Back in 1994 Professor Alison Macfarlane published “Where to Be Born?” an important analysis of the statistics on birthplace and safety. In 2011, the Birthplace in England Programme (in collaboration with the University of Oxford and King’s College London) compared outcomes for 65,000 low-risk women.

Professor Macfarlane at City also led a case study of one of the first midwifery units in the UK, showing that it gave women far more positive experiences of care and birth.

Recently, the Alongside Midwifery Unit Study and the NICE BirthPlace Action Study were the first to look at implementation challenges and strategies for scaling up midwifery units. Our researchers have been collaborating even further afield to develop good quality maternity facilities on a more global scale.

There are ongoing projects with the University of São Paulo and a network of birth centres in Brazil and with partners in Afghanistan, India and several African countries.

For two generations, women were told it was safer to have a baby in hospital. We know that stopping things that aren't evidence based is really difficult – they’re embedded in the way institutions and people are organised, the way they think, the way they’re used to operating. We’re identifying what’s happening and why, so we can provide the evidence to trigger a cultural change.

– Professor Christine McCourt
Implementing evidence on birthplace into practice 6 minutes

Benefits and influence of this research

By publishing in journals, releasing press statements, and circulating evidence to service managers, the public and practitioners, City researchers have helped change policy and reform maternity services across the world.

The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence’s clinical guidelines were directly influenced by the Birthplace in England programme. And, supported by the ongoing work at the Centre for Maternal and Child Health Research, the number of midwifery units in England rose from 53 in 2010 to 173 in 2019. In that time, the percentage of births in these units increased from 5% to 14%.

More recently, despite an increased interest in out-of-hospital birth, availability of these facilities was reduced as a result of Covid-19 so the work on access continues. Our earlier work highlighted inequities in access too and a new project led by Dr Marina Daniele is also focusing on strategies to improve access for racialised women.

Many countries only offer birth in a hospital obstetric unit and influencing change is challenging. For this reason, in 2016, Dr Rocca-Ihenacho and a small group of midwifery leaders, academics and service users representatives, created the Midwifery Unit Network (MUNet), a community of practice with the aim of making MUs the mainstream birth setting for low-risk women and birthing people.

City, University of London provided support to the network form the beginning and MUNet progressed to support the opening and scaling up of midwifery units in countries like Spain, the Czech Republic and Bulgaria, where birth settings options were almost inexistent previously.

The Network’s Facebook group has over 8,000 members sharing resources and best practices. MUNet has also started the Global Confederation of Birth Centre Networks which will help lead to new maternity units in low- and middle-income countries.

A team at City in collaboration with MUNet developed the first European Midwifery Unit Standards to help all stakeholders implement or improve midwifery units in Europe, using evidence and expert review and wide consultation.

There has already been wide interest from around the world and the network and the Standards have been endorsed by the National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE).

The MU Standards have been translated and published in Spanish, Italian, Czech, French, Dutch, Portuguese and Brazilian and Dr Rocca-Ihenacho has collaborated with Saudi Arabia and Afghan to adapt the standards to local contexts.

A Midwifery Units Self-Assessment-tool has been developed to support services in using the Standards for service improvement and pilot studies are in process and in 2022 the Midwifery Units Self-Assessment (MUSA)- Framework was created, which provided a step-by-step guidance for MU quality improvement.

Work is also in process, led by Dr Bradley and Dr Leister, to support implementation in low and middle-income countries and provide evidence of outcomes on a more global scale.

In many countries, hospital care is not affordable for all and it is not always accessible to those with medical complications. Overcrowding and overwork can also lead of care that is not kind or safe.

We are looking at the options for developing more small midwife-led units to address these problems and gather evidence on whether the outcomes are comparable in other contexts.

These projects are working together to shift the focus away from childbirth in hospital as the routine. Women should have a choice – not just for ethical reasons, but because the evidence shows there are real cost and health benefits too.

Did you know?

Graphic: Baby

The number of Midwifery Units rose from 53 in 2010 to 97 in 2016, with the percentage of births in these units increasing from 5% to 14%.

Share this case study

Details of this research

  • Dr Lucia Rocca-Ihenacho (Principal Investigator)
  • Professor Christine McCourt (Principal Investigator)
  • Dr Cassandra Yuill (Co-Investigator)
  • Dr Marina Daniele (Co-Investigator)
  • Dr Nathalie Leister (Co-Investigator)
  • Dr Susan Bradley (Co-Investigator)
  • Professor Alison Macfarlane (Co-Investigator)
  • Research status: Ongoing

    Topic: healthcare, midwifery, policy

    Industry/sector: Healthcare

    Project partners/stakeholders:

    School of Health & Psychological Sciences

    Department of Midwifery and Radiography

    National Institute for Health Research

    What's happening

    • Event

      Oct 30

      Is it really dangerous to have your baby at night?

      This event will focus on the findings on neonatal mortality in relation to the timing of birth, using the City Birth Cohort.

      Monday, 30th October 2023, 12:30 – 13:30

      Location: Northampton Square, Room MG26, Myddelton Street Building, or via MS Teams

      Audience: Public

    • News

      THUMB FINDER - SHPS STUDENT AWARDS CEREMONY 2023

      Monday, 19th June 2023

      School of Health & Psychological Sciences Student Awards 2023

      The Awards celebrate exceptional academic achievement by School students, and outstanding enhancement of the student experience by its staff and student representatives.

    • News

      Pregnant woman holding a clock

      Thursday, 15th June 2023

      Giving birth outside of working hours in England is safe, suggests study

      New study shares in-depth analysis of the factors affecting birth and its timing, suggesting that for almost all births, being born ‘out of hours’ is as safe as being born during working hours.

    Help us to improve this page

    City, University of London

    The University of business, practice and the professions

    • Library Services
    • Moodle
    • Email
    • Staff directory
    • Term dates
    • Book a room
    • Schools and departments

    Back to top

    Contact us

    Make an enquiry

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • Weibo
    • WeChat
    Social media directory

    Find us

    City, University of London
    Northampton Square
    London EC1V 0HB
    United Kingdom

    Campus map

    Our global campuses

    • London
    • Dubai

    Awards and accreditations

    • Athena SWAN: Bronze Award
    • Stonewall: LGBTQ+ Inclusive employer - Silver Award 2023 logo
    • UKRI Research England logo

    Useful links

    • Accessibility
    • Privacy policy
    • Cookies
    • City Store
    • Support City
    • Work for City
    • City Magazine
    • 中文

    © 2023 City, University of London

    University of London