Enablers and barriers to local level and urban food policy in England.
- 2011 - PhD candidate, Centre for Food Policy, City, University of London. Supervisors: David Barling, Tim Lang, Bettina Bock Funded under the PUREFOOD project, a Marie Curie Initial Training network, EU Grant Agreement Number 264719
- 2008 - 2010 MSc Food Policy, City University London
- 2004 PG Dip Periodicals Journalism, London College of Printing
- 1994 - 1997 BA (Hons) Classics, Corpus Christi College, Cambridge
Food strategies and food policy groups have been formed in several local government areas all over England in recent years, involving actors from the public, civil society and (sometimes) private sectors. However in the UK national policy direction over food has remained overwhelmingly neoliberal, and a concerted food policy has proved elusive. The UK's former Labour government signalled an intention to reassert itself over food policy with the publication of the Food 2030and Food Matters reports and the formation of a (short-lived) national Food Policy Council, but the current Coalition government has not advanced this work.
Moreover, the localism rhetoric of successive governments might appear to empower the local level to pursue its own policy direction over a number of food-related policy and service areas, but there are doubts as to whether so-called 'new localism' constitutes real devolution of power or simply the permission to pick from a set menu of choices, whilst national government may seize back control at any point if a 'wrong' decision is taken.
This begs the question of how far sub-national food policy initiatives can be effective mechanisms for reconfiguring the food system around a local context, or whether more subtle influence is retained by the national and international levels, which are invested with the potential for change. This is the central question addressed by the project proposed in this paper, which identifies the groups of actors from the public sector, civil society and (sometimes) private sector that formulate, advocate, and in some cases implement local-level food policy as policy networks.
The research project uses governance and new institutionalist theories to investigate the enablers and barriers to effective formulation and implementation of food policy at the sub-national, predominantly urban, level in England. It will consider governance of the food strategy or food policy group itself, the local-level governance context as defined by the administrative boundaries in which they exist, and the multi-level governance context. It aims to discover how the institutions within and between each of these governance dimensions interact and influence each other, and how tensions are played out between them.
The study design is five case studies, in Greater London, the London Borough of Islington, Bristol, Manchester, and County Durham. Data collection is through document analysis, meeting observation, and semi-structured interviews.
Why it matters for food policy
The findings may be used to strengthen local level and urban food policy, and help inform the development of effective new policies that are appropriate to their governance context. It may also lead some actors to adapt their processes and frameworks to increase the potential effectiveness of strategies.
- Halliday, J., Barling, D. (forthcoming) A multi-level governance perspective of local and urban food policy, in Wiskerke, J. (ed) Purefood book (final title to be announced)
- Moragues, A.; Morgan, K.; Moschitz, H.; Neimane, I.; Nilsson, H.; Pinto, M.; Rohracher,H.; Ruiz, R.; Thuswald, M.; Tisenkopfs, T. and Halliday, J. (2013) Urban Food Strategies: the rough guide to sustainable food systems. Document developed in the framework of the FP7 project FOODLINKS (GA No. 265287).
- Mitchell, J., Crawley, H., Halliday, J., Vann Thrasher, L. (2012) A Question of Taste: A review of flavourings of foods and drinks in the UK, First Steps Nutrition Trust.
- 2005 - 2011 Numerous news, comments and features for food industry publication FoodNavigator.com 2009 A short guide to sustainable agriculture, SAI Platform.
Conference presentations and panels
- 'Can local and urban food policy groups lead the charge against food poverty?' 5th AESOP Sustainable Food Planning, Montpellier, October 2013
- 'Un cadre commun entre de multiples expériences de stratégie alimentaire urbaine?', Symposium of the UNESCO Chair on World Food Systems: Quelles ressources pour nourrir les villes?, Montpellier, February 2013
- 'Barriers and enablers to the effective development and implementation of food strategies: a case study of the London Food Board', IUFN Hungry City, Paris, December 2012
- 'Governance and institutionalist theory: tools for understanding the barriers and enablers to effective urban food strategies', 4th AESOP Sustainable Food Planning, Berlin, November 2012
- 'Barriers and enablers to urban, peri-urban and regional food provision within urban governance: case studies of Sheffield and Bristol', Agriculture in an Urbanizing Society conference, Wageningen, April 2012
UK food policy, Urban food strategies, food policy councils, local government, multi-level governance, new institutionalism, sustainability, corporate social responsibility, food flavourings industry.